13 Mysteries to Watch if You Love Hannah Swensen and “Murder, She Baked”
If you’re a fan of Murder, She Baked or the Hannah Swensen Mysteries, you know there’s something special about a cozy mystery filled with small-town charm, a touch of romance, and just enough suspense to keep you guessing. These shows offer the perfect mix of heartwarming characters, quirky townsfolk, and engaging mysteries, making them a beloved escape for cozy mystery lovers. Whether you love the culinary twist of baking mysteries or the down-to-earth sleuthing of amateur detectives, we’ve rounded up a list of shows that capture that same irresistible blend of intrigue and coziness. Grab a blanket, settle in, and discover your next binge-worthy mystery series!
13. The Cases of Mystery Lane
Hallmark’s The Cases of Mystery Lane follows married couple Birdie and Alden (played by Aimee Garcia and Paul Campbell) as they dive into the world of amateur sleuthing.
Solving both their marital issues and crimes, this couple uses their different skills and viewpoints to find clues and common ground. Their quirky partnership brings both tension and laughs as they approach mysteries.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
Like Hannah and Mike, Birdie and Alden have a delightful chemistry that keeps the mystery lighthearted yet intriguing. Fans of cozy domestic mysteries with a mix of romance will enjoy watching this duo navigate both marriage and murder.
12. Agatha Raisin
Based on the books by M.C. Beaton the Agatha Raisin series follows a formidable former PR executive turned amateur sleuth (played by Ashley Jensen) who solves quirky crimes in the quaint Cotswolds of the English countryside. With her unique sense of fashion and a flair for the dramatic, she finds herself constantly at odds with locals and suspects alike. Agatha’s knack for attracting trouble, insatiable curiosity, and dogged determination leads her and her friends to become involved with multiple murder mysteries - whether the local police want her help or not.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
Agatha’s small-town charm, humor, and a mix of romance make her a captivating character, much like Hannah. The series captures the blend of suspense and wit that Hannah Swensen Mysteries fans love, with each case offering a fresh twist.
11. Pushing Daisies
This whimsical series follows Ned (played by Lee Pace), a pie-maker with the magical ability to bring the dead back to life for one minute—just long enough to solve crimes. Helping him solve these murder mysteries are a grumpy PI (played by Chi McBride), a smitten musical waitress (played by Kristin Chenoweth), his resurrected childhood sweetheart (played by Anna Friel) and beloved formerly-deceased dog Digby. Set in a vibrant world with quirky characters, each episode mixes mystery with fantasy.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
The series’ warm, lighthearted feel and the cozy pie shop setting will resonate with fans of Hannah’s bakery. The show’s unique storytelling style and offbeat humor add a dash of whimsy to every mystery, making it a delightful watch.
10. Pie in the Sky
A retired English detective (played by Richard Griffiths) opens a restaurant but finds himself continually called back to solve cases. Set against the backdrop of his restaurant, this series delivers mysteries with a culinary twist.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
Fans will appreciate the show’s focus on food and mystery, echoing Hannah’s love for baking and solving crimes. The character’s charming personality and dual focus on cooking and crime-solving make it a cozy fit.
9. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries follows “Ro” (played by Candace Cameron Bure) a librarian and true crime enthusiast, who investigates crimes in her seemingly quiet town. Each episode brings her closer to uncovering hidden truths with the help of friends and “Real Murders” club members.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
Fans of Hannah will relate to Aurora’s small-town charm and her tenacity for uncovering mysteries. The show balances light suspense with endearing relationships, much like Murder, She Baked and other beloved Hallmark Mysteries.
8. Garage Sale Mysteries
In the Garage Sale Mysteries, Jennifer Shannon (played by Lori Loughlin), an antique owner, has a knack for finding hidden secrets at garage sales and estate auctions. Her keen eye for details and clues helps her uncover the truth behind puzzling cases. With the support of her family and best friend, she investigates antiques and solves mysterious murders.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
Like Hannah, Jennifer balances a small business with solving crimes, making her relatable and down-to-earth. The show’s unique “find the clue” premise and mystery-filled storyline will keep cozy mystery fans engaged.
7. Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators
In Shakespeare & Hathaway, private detectives Luella Shakespeare (played by Jo Joyner) and Frank Hathaway (played by Mark Benton) tackle a range of peculiar mysteries in the scenic birthplace of William Shakespeare, Stratford-Upon-Avon. Their odd-couple dynamic is packed with humor and surprises.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
The charming rural setting, lighthearted banter, and unpredictable plots make this a fun ride for cozy mystery enthusiasts. Fans of Hannah Swensen will appreciate the witty, character-driven storytelling and the duo’s unorthodox approach to solving cases.
6. Chronicle Mysteries
In Hallmark’s The Chronicle Mysteries, podcaster Alex McPherson (played by Alison Sweeney) dives into cold cases, using her platform to uncover long-buried truths in her hometown. With the help of the handsome local newspaper editor Drew Godfrey (played by Benjamin Ayres), she digs deeper into the mysteries that intrigue her audience and seeks justice for victims of cold and current cases..
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
Fans will enjoy seeing Alison Sweeney in another role as a sleuth in a new setting!
Alex’s determination to solve cases, coupled with her community connections, creates a similar feel to Hannah’s small-town sleuthing. This series combines suspense with a homey feel, perfect for cozy mystery fans.
5. Mrs. Sidhu Investigates
While some might call caterer Mrs. Sidhu (played by Meera Syal) a busybody, we call her another charming amateur sleuth. This charismatic caterer, finds herself solving crimes that often intersect with her culinary work.
Between caring for her son, cooking tasty meals for clients, and offering sage auntie advice, Mrs. Sidhu also finds time to investigate mysteries when those she cares about are in trouble. Though DCI Burton (played by Craig Parkinson) is initially reluctant to have her involved, he begins to trust her gut and enjoy her food. Her charm and wit set her apart as she uncovers hidden secrets.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
With food and mystery intertwined, fans of Hannah’s bakery adventures will enjoy Mrs. Sidhu’s culinary-themed investigations. The series’ blend of cozy mystery and humor gives it a warm, approachable feel.
4. Murder, She Wrote
This iconic series follows Jessica Fletcher (played by the acclaimed Angela Lansbury), a mystery writer and amateur detective, who seems to find herself at the center of murder mysteries wherever she goes. Her keen observational skills make her a master at solving cases.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
Jessica Fletcher’s small-town charm and gentle yet astute crime-solving style are sure to appeal to Hannah’s fans. The show’s cozy setting and engaging plots make it a staple in the cozy mystery genre.
3. Gourmet Detective
In Hallmark’s Gourmet Detective Mysteries, a culinary expert teams up with a detective to solve crimes in the world of fine dining.
This relationship definitely takes some time to develop as Maggie first finds Henry pretentious and she isn't what you would call a “foodie” while he is an acclaimed chef. Their love-hate dynamic adds a fun twist to each mystery as they navigate clues and culinary delights.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
With its focus on food and mystery, Gourmet Detective gives a fresh take on crime-solving that will resonate with fans of Hannah’s bakery. The chemistry between the lead characters and their culinary sleuthing adds an extra layer of fun.
2. Morning Show Mysteries
Morning Show Mysteries follows Billie Blessings (played by Holly Robinson Peete), a morning show host and chef, who often finds herself entangled in mysteries that affect her community. Her unique perspective as both a media personality and amateur sleuth helps her tackle crimes.
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
The food-themed mysteries and strong lead character make this show a perfect choice for fans of Hannah Swensen. Billie’s dedication to uncovering the truth while balancing her career brings a relatable and intriguing dynamic to each episode.
1. Curious Caterer Mysteries
In the Curious Caterer Mysteries, small business owner and caterer Goldy Berry (played by Nikki Deloach) stumbles into mysteries in her small town while balancing her love for cooking with her knack for solving crimes. Each case takes her deeper into the secrets of her community and allows her to get closer to the serious new detective (played by Andrew W. Walker.)
Why Hannah Swensen Fans Will Love It:
Much like Hannah, Goldy’s culinary talents and detective skills bring a charming duality to her character. Fans will appreciate the cozy vibe, small-town setting, and the fun mix of food and mystery that this series offers.