The Best Hallmark+ Mystery Premieres of 2024
If you’re a fan of cozy mysteries with engaging plots and unforgettable characters, Hallmark+ delivered some of the best new premieres in 2024—exclusive to the streaming platform! Unlike the Hallmark Channel’s traditional offerings, these mysteries debuted solely on Hallmark+, giving subscribers access to a fresh slate of captivating whodunits.
From small-town sleuths to heartwarming tales of holiday intrigue, these premieres have captured viewers with their perfect mix of suspense and charm. Here are the standout mystery movies and series that made their Hallmark+ debut this year, offering thrilling stories you won’t find anywhere else.
Though be sure to check out our list of the Best 2024 Mysteries to Premiere on Hallmark Channel!
3. The Jane Mysteries
In The Jane Mysteries, Singer Jane Da Silva (played by Jodie Sweetin) returns to her hometown after her uncle’s death when she inherits The Foundation, a charity detective agency that seeks to right wrongs. Aided by her Aunt Sadie (played by Paris Jefferson) and Detective John Cameron (played by Stephen Huszar,) Jane solves cold cases and helps those in need.
The Jane Mysteries: A Deadly Prescription - Jane and John seek justice for a teenager wrongfully accused of killing a pharmacist.
The Jane Mysteries: Murder at the Moseby - During her alma mater’s annual Edgar Allan Poe Festival, Jane goes undercover to help her college boyfriend solve a crime he may have witnessed years ago.
The Jane Mysteries: Too Much to Lose - While preparing for the Children's Hospital Gala, Jane and John investigate a journalist who disappeared after winning a game show, uncovering a dangerous world of blackmail and fraud.
2. Aurora Teagarden Mysteries
In the new Aurora Teagarden Mysteries (prequels to the existing Aurora Teagarden Mysteries), we meet young Aurora “Ro” Teagarden (played by Skyler Samuels) as she returns to Lawrenceton to earn her postgraduate degree, involving her passion for true crime books, and finds herself involved with real current cases to be solved.
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Lesson in Murder - When a student from Aurora's true crime literature class is found murdered outside the diner where she works, Aurora takes it upon herself to solve the mystery.
Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Death at the Diner - Aurora’s new boyfriend becomes the prime suspect when the owner of the diner where she works is found dead.
1. Mistletoe Murders
In the Hallmark series Mistletoe Murders, based on the Audible Original series, Emily Lane (played by Sarah Drew) owns a Christmas store in the small town of Fletcher’s Grove. However, when murders begin occurring, Emily uses the skills from her secret past to begin sleuthing.
Crossing paths with Detective Sam Wilner (played by Peter Mooney), a connection is born, but the detective learns there is more to Emily than meets the eye and he can’t help suspecting her motives.
Episode 1 - Poison in a Pear Tree Part 1
Episode 2 - Poison in a Pear Tree Part 2
Episode 3 - Peril of the Belles Part 1
Episode 4 - Peril of the Belles Part 2
Episode 5 - Death of a Humbug Part 1
Episode 6 - Death of a Humbug Part 2
